The Lost Weekend - Part 2
- 05 May
The Lost Weekend, Part 2: Exploring the thirteen game mechanics
In my previous post on gamification, I began exploring the subject of gamification, why games are so popular and, at times, addictive.
I introduced you to 13 game mechanics and here I will delve a little deeper into these, as identified by Karl Kapp1
Here is a reminder of the 13 game mechanics:
Characters, such as those appearing in novels, are an important element which helps immerse the gamer (or learner) in the game environment. They are a vital part of the storytelling. They help make an emotional connection.
In her book eLearning and the Science of Instruction, third edition *Ruth Clark refers to characters as ‘avatars’ or ‘agents’ and their inclusion is part of 'the personalisation principle'.
Although, characters don't need to have a human appearance, evidence shows that non-human characters should be human-like. I like to think of it as the 'Disney Effect' - how else could you worry for a snowman, who has a carrot for a nose and sticks for arms, as he dreams of the warmth of the sun?
*the fourth edition of the above book was published March 2016
The ‘personalisation principle’ is similar for gamification. The learner, when taking on the role of a character (these are called avatars), practises behaviours in the game until they are mastered. Seeing yourself carrying out tasks and problem solving as a character (a first person view), has less impact than seeing the character doing the same (a third person view). And, if the learner is able to adapt a character's appearance to resemble themselves, it has an even greater impact than just choosing a character to become.
Avatars are not the only characters in the game. Just as in a novel, the avatar may interact with other characters and it is important that the 'story' characters help keep the pace going. Finally, there is another type of character which can have a positive impact on learning in games. Those acting as mentors (Ruth Clark refers to these as pedagogical agents) provide instruction and encouragements. These also have a positive impact especially where speech, rather than text, is used and the language is in a conversational tone. This all helps create an immersive environment.
The story, like the characters, is essential for gamification. It engages and guides people through the game. It provides relevance, context and meaning. When we think about it, all games we play have an element of storytelling. In Cluedo, a murder has taken place and the players look at the clues on the cards to help them decide whether it was Miss Scarlet with the rope in the library, or someone far more devious! Even a game of chess is a story of kingdom against kingdom and what strategy will help us conquer all.
Because we remember stories better than random facts, the story will help learners relate the game to their own goals making the learning more powerful and enabling better recall in work-based situations. This is why using scenarios are effective in elearning or classroom settings - gamification takes storytelling to a higher level. According to Kapp, there are four story elements which we will explore at a later date.
Building in mystery appeals to our sense of curiosity and our emotional state. What will pique our curiosity? Things which are incomplete, complex or where there are inconsistencies. Also, surprise and novelty will evoke our cognitive curiosity. Our sensory curiosity should also be stimulated through visuals, sound and movement.
Building in a sense of fantasy can help the learner experience situations they have not been presented with before. These, in effect, create metaphors, analogies and vivid mental images which increase and improve learners' memory.
I think back to my own CSI Wii game example where I only had some of the facts and clues that were hidden in the visual environment. There were inconsistencies in the information I was gathering and I can honestly say, I've never before had to investigate a crime, but the fantasy elements helped me draw on experiences learned in the game and assimilate to past experiences and knowledge, even though I've never attended a crime scene in my life!
There are three types of challenges we learn about in Kapp's book on gamification: conflict, competition and co-operation. Challenges allow us to use higher-level thinking to solve problems and keep our attention going. However, as designers, we have to be careful to get the challenge level right.
I call this the ‘Goldilocks effect’. Her porridge had to be not too hot and not too cold to be just right to eat. Equally, the challenge should not be too difficult as to frustrate the learner, thus demotivating them; nor should it be too easy that they become bored. Neither will help learning happen. The challenge should be 'just right' to maintain motivation and the flow state mentioned in Part 1.
According to a recent survey by TalentLMS the most preferred gamification techniques by learners is that of 'levelling up'. That may surprise you - when the question of what we (L&D professionals) at the World of Learning in 2015 thought people who play games would prefer, most hands went up for points or competing with peers.
Having been sucked in by only the CSI game, my own experience was the challenge of getting to the next level in the game. I didn't care so much about collecting bugs (entomology was Grissom’s thing) although enough bugs would give me a bonus crime scene to solve; I wasn’t interested in competing against others either. However, points mean a lot to a lot of people, coming second as the most preferred element in the survey when playing games. More about rewards later!
Building in ‘levels’ provides ‘easy’ to ‘intermediate’ challenges, which cater for different levels of abilities. Each level will not only introduce new challenges and therefore new learning, but the opportunity to practise skills and knowledge learned in previous levels. Levels will help the story progress, increasing mystery and maintain the curve of interest- 'levelling up' motivates progression and evokes a feeling of accomplishment.
Setting goals provides a clear purpose, helps focus and establishes measurable outcomes for the learner to achieve. In order to get to the next level, the learner may have to achieve a number of measurable goals. Each level will have its own set of goals which, eventually, will lead to the overall goal. Goals will challenge the learner and, when achieved, act as an incentive to continue to achieve the overall goal.
There are three rules for the player:
- Operational - rules on how to play the game e.g. you can't enter the witness's office without a warrant and you can't get a warrant without collecting sufficient evidence
- Implicit - these are rules on how to behave and are implied rather than written down. You could call them rules of etiquette and would be mostly applied in a multiplayer game
- Instructional - these feel similar to operational rules but they provide an opportunity for learning
Like goals, this can help learners focus and encourages the prioritisation of tasks. Playing 'against the clock' can help speed up mental agility and help us carry out tasks efficiently - skills which are transferrable back in the workplace. Taking my CSI game as an example - I was very inefficient in my deductions, which was the cause of staying up until ‘stupid-o'clock’ playing detective. The reason? I refused to ask my mentor, Catherine, for help. I was stubborn and wanted to crack the case myself. I may have got the killer but maybe at the expense of another victim? Not great, if the game is to encourage team working and efficiency. This links to the instructional rule above.
This is not the same as giving direct feedback in a traditional elearning module. Feedback is constant and seamless. It will be visual, auditory and possibly multi-sensory. Learners will experience feedback in relation to where they are in the game, in relation to others and/or the goal. It may emulate the type of feedback people receive in real life if they carried out the same tasks, or explored the same environment.
Take my CSI example; I received visual and auditory feedback following every action I took. If I decided to explore a specific corner of the crime scene by moving the arrow keys on the controller, feedback would be constant and involve seeing (or hearing) different things as I moved towards the destination, all of which I would mentally digest for later reference. If I chose to collect evidence with the correct tool from my CSI bag, I would see the evidence had been collected. If I chose the wrong tool, feedback would either be that the evidence wasn't collected or I may have been told what that tool would be used for to help me re-evaluate and make another choice.
Essentially, constant feedback helps the learner learn from their mistakes and allows them freedom to fail. I like to think of it as the ‘cause and effect’ principle where everything they do will have a consequence. Feedback may present itself as visual cues and results of actions through the game. Feedback also acts as a guide to help the learner learn. It doesn't tell you what you should do - rather, it allows you to work it out and do it differently the next time you encounter the same or similar obstacle.
This is all about how building in the right level of uncertainty influences motivation to continue with the game and, therefore, achieve the goal. The uncertainty factor, whether it is gaining points or reaching levels, releases dopamine levels in the brain which can increase motivation levels by 50%.
According to Liraz Margalit Ph.D.in her article ‘Why are the Candy Crushes of the world dominating our lives’, the reward is more pleasurable the more surprising it is, and is 'strongly rooted in our evolution'.
The uncertainty of whether rewards are gained has a positive effect on the emotional aspect of the learning experience which, according to Kapp1, improves encoding and later recall.
When we encourage unlimited replay, we will encourage learning through repetition and practise. This, as with feedback, gives permission to fail, re-evaluates decision making and behaviour, encourages exploration and prompts curiosity.
Replayability allows the learner to test out new ideas and learn from mistakes. It is important to maintain motivation by building in support should the learner continue to make the same mistakes. For example, rather than tell the learner what they should have done, offer another task which is easier to complete. This will help to rebuild their confidence, practise the skills and 'level up' again. The next time they level up and are faced with those tasks they failed in before, the same skills will be called for again once they've had an opportunity to 'replay' and become more proficient.
The quality of the visual design is vital to the overall sensory experience for the learner, even in the simplest of games to ensure that the visual layout is appropriately stimulating. The quality of the visuals can make or break the success of the game. If the game design itself is poor, good visuals won't make it any better; but if the game design is good, well-designed visuals will make the overall experience great because the learner becomes immersed in the environment.
Attention to detail is crucial when it comes to aesthetics however, realism is not. Characters do not have to have a realistic appearance to make a connection with the learner. In fact, if you try for a realistic look and it isn't quite there, it can have the opposite effect. Characters and objects can work just as well if they are simplified or cartoon-like.
Depending on the type of content you are building, different style graphics may work better with one than the other. For example, high fidelity, realistic visuals and authentic environments tend to work better for higher order thinking skills, whereas simplistic game visuals can work best for facts.
Whatever look you go for, the important things to consider are the quality of the graphics and how they work together.
Finally, we come to what some might think of as what really makes gamification. Rewards are certainly useful game mechanics to consider. As we read above, they play a part of chance which releases dopamine levels in our brains which, in turn, motivates us to continue with the game. However, we need to think carefully when building in rewards. Rewards should be integral to the game rather than the focus of the game. If we are not careful, the learner's goal will be reward focused rather than learning/goal focused.
Receiving rewards motivates. There are two types of motivation we should consider: intrinsic and extrinsic.
Intrinsic motivation is where we do something for its own sake or for the positive feeling of achievement. When we think of intrinsic rewards this is the satisfaction we get from carrying out a task itself not from the results of completing the task.
Extrinsic motivation is where we are motivated by receiving something good or avoiding something bad. For example, extrinsic rewards might be reaching a certain grade or achieving the top 5 on a leader board or reaching the next level.
Link rewards to tasks in the game instead of awarding random prizes or rewards. Extrinsic rewards have a positive impact on intrinsic motivation when they are built into the feedback on how the learner is doing. It is important to plan for both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation when considering a reward system.
To leave you with a final thought from Karl Kapp1: "..the story, the challenge, the sense of control, decision making and a sense of mastery - these are the elements of games that are of the most value". So, when considering bringing gamification into your blended approach, focus on these not just rewards, badges and leader boards.
1Kapp, K.M. (2012) The gamification of learning and instruction; game-based methods and strategies for training and education Pfeiffer 1st Ed. (Kindle)
Laura Layton-James is an Online Learning Consultant at The Training Foundation. Contact her by emailing: email@example.com or by calling: 02476 411288
Comments (1 comment)
- 25 Aug
Is lunch the answer to climate change?
I read a conversation on LinkedIn recently. As a result, I was in very real danger of being shaken to my core. It turns out that not everyone stops working and eats lunch with their colleagues! To be fair, it wasn’t that black-and-white fact that discombobulated me; more, it was the strength of reaction from those who choose not to take time out with their team. It’s not my place – and...
- 02 Jun
How do you transfer learning?
Learning Transfer is another significant elephant in the room when it comes to discussions between L&D and their senior business manager colleagues, whether in public or private sector organisations.We attend a number of L&D-related exhibitions every year and talk to a lot of L&D professionals on a daily basis about ‘quality-assuring’ Learning and Development.Recently we have been...
- 23 Mar
Nerves are a good thing, right?
A manager once said to me: ‘The day you walk into a training room and you’re not feeling nervous, is the day you should walk out.’ This got me thinking.Why would he say that?On reflection I think my manager was right: feeling nervous is a sign that my engine is running and I’m ready to go. I read somewhere that nerves and excitement are the same thing with different outfits on! If...
- 18 Mar
The Lost Weekend - Part 1
The Lost Weekend Part 1 – an exploration of game-mechanics and gamification on our learning motivation It's three o'clock in the morning. Where did that last 6 hours go? Am I in a time warp and have been bounced forward in a blink of an eye? No, I've been collecting evidence, visiting different venues, asking lots of questions of different people. I'm very fastidious - I don't leave a room...
- 11 Mar
Training Delivery 'Style' - Art or Science?
Art: an expression or application of human creative skill and imagination Science: the intellectual and practical activity encompassing the systematic study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world A rather subjective topic but can it be both? While I think there are some people that have a natural ability to perform well when standing in front of people, there are...
- 25 Feb
FLASH Learning Groups and Spaced Learning
Spaced Learning is a concept that’s been around for quite some time, and interest has recently reappeared in several social media forums and groups. Dr Will Thalheimer wrote a comprehensive and enlightening paper Spaced Learning Over Time which can be downloaded for free from his site: http://www.work-learning.com/catalog.html One of the problems we often encounter in the workplace is the...
- 19 Jan
When does a trickle turn into a flood?
How many times have you had a delegate ask “what time are we due to finish, only I’ve got to leave at X o’clock for … (add in here any reason they give - their transport, an appointment/meeting etc)? I’m not talking about family crises or any other reason outside their control. After all, life overtakes all of us at times, doesn’t it? Have you found yourself agreeing...
- 17 Dec
7 top tips on building rapport online
You meet new delegates in the classroom and immediately you start to build rapport with eye contact and body language. But how do you do this online?It can be challenging, but we’ve got a few tips to get you started…Get the ball rolling early on…start the process early on by sending a welcome email, perhaps offering to give them a phone call before the course starts. You could even do...
- 10 Dec
I need feedback like I need a hole in the head
I received a really thoughtful piece of feedback from a colleague recently. It was unsolicited, specific and heartfelt. And it made my day.The team I manage includes nine high-end learning and development consultants. We’re a really accomplished group, with years of professional and life experience behind us. I value their opinions, their capability and their creativity. We’re a...
- 26 Nov
Experience in What?
With LinkedIn becoming ever popular as a networking tool, I am increasingly interested in some of the more inventive job titles around. For instance:Lean Consultant – is that a particularly athletic individual, or someone who practises a ‘lean’ approach to work?Creative Apparel Manager - ??Head of Saucepans – ok, I made that one up.I also find myself asking the question; “what does...
- 12 Nov
6 keys to structuring great learning
In this blog, we’re going to explore critical components of great learning events.We all want to support effective learning with a robust and sturdy structure, don’t we? It’s useful to have milestones to reach or touchpoints to achieve when delivering our sessions. Don’t get me wrong; structure doesn’t mean that we’re confined to boundaries from which we mustn’t deviate; it’s...
- 22 Oct
SMEs are from Mars
As an L&D professional, have you ever had responsibility for consulting with operational Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) about training needs, perhaps as a result of a product launch, system, process change or any issue that can be fixed by training?If so, did both parties understand what the other needed from the conversation? Did you have a clear idea of what you needed to achieve?Here’s some...
- 08 Oct
Managing People? Its a piece of cake
I watched the final of The Great British Bake Off last night. Those of you who know me will know that this is quite an admission; my TV viewing normally revolves around documentaries, crime and current affairs.Anyway, I’ve now come to terms with the fact that I’m not averse to a bit of gentle mid-week TV viewing.If you’re familiar with the concept, you’ll know that The Great British Bake...
- 01 Oct
Achieving the 'Trainer State' - Part 2
Part 2In Part 1, we considered the areas of Confidence and Physiology when looking to achieve what we call the ‘trainer state’.In this part, we’ll be looking at another two key areas to consider in ‘managing self’ – congruence and competence. We’ll also be looking at ways to help avoid burn-out.So, what other areas do we need to consider when ‘managing self’, to achieve and...
- 24 Sep
How does your garden grow?
I became a gardener a few years ago – just like that. I knew it was going to happen sometime in my life, I just didn’t know when. It happened when the circumstances were right for me to embrace the pleasures of tending my garden. The encyclopaedia of gardening and the index of gardening books, ignored and dusted on the bookcase for 25 years, finally got pored over each night for...
- 17 Sep
Wants and needs are the same thing, right? Wrong!
It occurred to me recently, in that sudden, unbidden way that ideas usually pounce, that I’ve worked in Learning and Development for 23 years. That’s exactly half the time I’ve existed. I haven’t yet worked out whether to be thrilled at this achievement, or alarmed that life’s moving so quickly.I’ve been really lucky and I’ve had the chance to work with people across...
- 27 Aug
The Magnificent Seven questions for an L&D ‘Online Learning Strategy’
Has the task of writing the L&D strategy landed on your desk? Or, perhaps the strategy is already set in stone but you are considering how to ‘future-proof’ it in terms of offering blended solutions and learning technologies? In either scenario, please read on….Here are The Magnificent Seven questions to consider when writing your L&D Online Learning Strategy.1. What are the business...
- 16 Jul
The language of learning…
Love them or hate them, acronyms are everywhere. They seem to have increased in use since texting and Tweeting have become so popular. An acronym in a text or Tweet says so much more in so few characters - CUL8R (see you later). They have become ubiquitous. Although, what we often refer to as acronyms are more like a version of text shorthand: a set of letters and/or numbers we would...
- 02 Jul
Refreshing Times Ahead
‘If we are to meet future business needs, we need to invest in our own capability today.’(CIPD L&D Report 2015: Evolving Roles, Enhancing Skills, pg.18) Want to refresh your knowledge and gain valuable CPD? You know what they say in L&D……repetition is the mother of all learning! TAP Training is launching a number of ‘Masterclass CPD’ certificated refresher one-day programmes for our...
- 03 Jun
How Creativity Overcame Consistency
Many of you will know that here at The Training Foundation we have a learning portal called TAP Academy, where all our course materials are stored, meaning that every online student has the same access to the same materials. Great for consistency, especially when we have a number of tutors delivering each course and many delegates at any one time. All of our boxes are ticked, we reach the...
- 27 May
From boring to brilliant presentations
This was a great piece of advice shared by a delegate on one of my recent courses which, if you think about it, can apply to eLearning, webinars and presentations. Having recently been invited to give a presentation at an NHS event on our Quality Assurance for eLearning programme, this quote kept popping into my mind. How could I make sure my presentation wasn’t boring?Here are my four...
- 06 May
Achieving the ‘Trainer State’
Staying positive and enthusing your learners or delegates throughout an entire course or programme is not always easy! The everyday demands of the workplace, commuting and life, in general, can drain even the most passionate of trainers.We know that having a positive, or ‘Trainer State’, is essential to creating an effective learning climate. But what, specifically, can we do to attain...
- 29 Apr
Teaching to the test, are we?
Ever been gently persuaded to just get your delegates through the test? Is the test the only aspect that your client looks at after your training? There are different methods of assessing your delegates, but how much does the test impact your delivery? These questions raise topics such as: the importance of ‘why?’, Kirkpatrick’s learning evaluation model and what you do to get your...
- 23 Apr
Personalised blended learning, what would your path be?
Blended learning can be a minefield. What is the correct blend? Should we use tablets? Should learners use their own technology? Will it be made available 24/7? All these questions and more, will be raised and answered, then a strategy designed and developed for the ‘correct blend’.With the meteoric rise in the use of technology, in and outside of the working environment, this has...
- 19 Mar
3 Skills for Success as a Learning & Development Professional
The Chartered Institute of Personnel & Development’s 2014 L&D Survey showed a significant wind of change blowing through the L&D community. The 1,081 respondents were asked to select their 3 top ‘skills for success’ for today’s L&D professional from a list of 10. Traditionally, top of the list would have been Training Design and Delivery but this was only 4th in this year’s Survey -...
- 04 Feb
Are blind spots impacting the capability and performance of your L&D team?
Research by The Training Foundation suggests that two common misconceptions are negatively impacting the quality and effectiveness of training in many organisations.It’s true that around 4 out of 5 trainers transition from a technical, subject matter background which is a catalyst for their change of role. Regrettably, many are more or less thrust into a training environment with little...
- 27 Jan
6 Steps to Set up a Learning Resource Centre
The Learning Resource Centre (LRC) is a library of learning content made accessible to employees who want to study, develop or learn. The creation of LRCs supports the development of those who use them, and will significantly help in both communicating and embedding an organisational ‘learning culture’.The LRC is arguably one of the best tools available to direct the practice of Self-Managed...